Two hate reads at a time?
Jun. 14th, 2023 10:48 pmI haven't been able to keep up completely with my Libby hold habit. A few books I had to just let go without starting them, including one about modern sea piracy that I did want to read, so I've stuck myself back on the queue.
I'm currently mid read on two different books, and I'm not enjoying either of them. But I'm not enjoying them in a way where instead of just being bored and stopping I'm getting aggravated and the reaction is driving me forward as some sort of psychic self-harm. They're starting to turn a little into hate reads.
The first book I'm trying to get through is Babel by R. F. Kuang. The premise is that the industrial revolution is driven by a magic involving linguistics and silver. And the blurb says the main character gets to take a stand against imperialism.
It's just so... ugh. I had picked it up and put it down a dozen times in bookshops because worldbuilding that engages with language is right up my alley, but the blurb always made me suspicious and I would put it back. A little while ago it was sitting on a display at the library so I thought, well, no risk there and I borrowed it. But it is turning out to be the sort of hamfisted lecture that I was worried it might be. And so far the worldbuilding has been disappointing. I'm not super far in, only to chapter 4, but I can only continue by making note after note of complaint after what feels like every other paragraph. I am hoping that eventually an interesting character will show up, or something interesting will happen, but so far no dice.
I wanted to hold off on specific gripes for after I was done with the whole thing but just starting to write about this book has now gotten me into sporking gear so here are a couple things I noted so far. They are by far not the only details I took issue with, but they're bits where I was like... huh? And they're kind of nitpicky details that I wouldn't have spent much thought on if they didn't sort of demonstrate what feels like a broader problem with the book so far, which is that no one seems to behave with a consistent logic beyond trying to make some sort of very basic point about how colonialism and racism are bad mmkay.
So a few examples of moments that annoyed me:
( Dumb stuff. )
Overall, my mood as I read this book has so far largely been, "Why?!" We'll see if that is the mood that continues.
The second book I'm sort of regretting starting is One For My Enemy. This got recced by the Librarything algorithm. It was sort of a NY crime family fantasy drawn from Slavic myth. Seemed appealing as a blurb.
My big problem with this book -- and again I haven't gotten that far -- is that I forgot how much I fucking hate het romances about 90% of the time. Just cannot bear the het cliches. The girl acting all "I can handle myself!" and the guy agreeing but insisting on babying her anyway, the weird borderline negging dialog that's meant to be banter, the dude jumping in to stop sexual harassment resulting in love at first sight. I hate it all. I'm kind of hoping that now that I've gotten past that setup the rest of the book will play out ok but honestly I doubt it. My man walked a drunk chick to the subway for a block and now he's like, "oh she's lovely and spirited and razor sharp and mean!" Ahhh I'm making myself annoyed all over again. I'm sure this aversion is the result of how fucking annoying it is for a guy to tell you all about yourself and get half it of wrong after having known you for 5 minutes but regardless of why I hate it I do.
The writing style also hits on one of my most massive pet peeves, which is aversion to the word "said" and the use of inappropriate verbs as replacement. A quote verb has to take the quote as its object. I know there is a drift away from that and some verbs have become commonplace exceptions but I still can't stand it when people "assure, 'I will do it.'" or "determine, 'Fine.'" You can't determine a "fine." You can be determined. You can say determinedly, but you cannot determine a word. This has been happening every other page and is honestly more annoying than the het.
But I'm also very early on in this book, so I'm going to keep going at least a little more and see if it gets better.


